Personalization in Cold Email Outreach: Connecting on a human level

Personalization has become the golden ticket to make your email marketing campaigns successful. And when it comes to cold email outreach, it's no different.

Gone are the days of generic , one-size-fits-all email blasts that land in the recipient's spam folder, never to be seen again. 

Today, personalization is the key to cutting through the digital noise and forging meaningful connections with your prospects.

In this blog post, we'll dive deep into the art and science of personalization in cold email outreach, exploring why it matters and how to do it effectively.

What is personalization in Cold Emails?

The question might strike your mind. What does cold email personalization mean exactly? Well, a definition could exactly help us to do it right.

Cold email personalization is the practice of customizing and tailoring your email messages to make them feel more relevant and engaging to the recipients, even though they may not have any prior relationship with you. 

It includes adding information in the email, like the recipient’s first name, their company name, and the project they are working on. It includes writing a unique message showing your prospect you've done your homework and want to catch their attention.  

It's an essential cold email marketing and cold email strategy for outreach designed to increase the chances of getting a response and ultimately achieving your desired goal, whether making a sale, scheduling a meeting, or building a professional relationship.

Why is personalization important?

Imagine receiving an email from a stranger. It's the usual sales pitch, filled with jargon and generic statements about how great their product or service is. You might read a few lines out of courtesy, but chances are, that email will be swiftly moved to your trash folder. 

Now, think about receiving an email that seems tailor-made for you. Its email body acknowledges your name, mentions your recent accomplishment, and offers a solution to a problem you've been facing. You'd be much more likely to read that email, right?

That's the power of personalization in cold email outreach. This email strategy transforms a cold, impersonal interaction into a warm, engaging conversation. ️

It shows the recipient that you've done your homework, care about their specific needs, and are not just another faceless salesperson trying to make a quick buck.

This helps you to increase your cold email open rate and enhance email deliverability. But to achieve this level of personalization, you need to follow some best practices.

Getting to know your audience

Personalization starts with getting to know your audience. Before you even begin writing a cold email, take the time to find out who your potential readers are. What problems do they have? What are their goals and worries? 

The more you learn, the better you can make your message fit them. Personalization is basically about doing your homework on your audience.

Study the people you want to reach out to. Understand why they're the right ones to target and how your solution can help them. Once you know your audience well, you can optimize your cold email by personalizing your approach differently. 

1. Segmentation

Start by segmenting the email addresses in your email list. Group your prospects based on standard industry, job title, or location characteristics. This allows you to create more targeted and relevant messages.

For example, if you are sending cold email about selling prospecting software, you should know that the right person to target will be a Sales manager or Sales lead. In simple terms, the one with the authority to decide about the product or service you are selling..

2. Creating buyer personas

Create detailed buyer personas for your ideal customers. These personas should cover demographic info, pain points, goals, and objections.

Keeping these personas in mind helps you write emails that connect with your audience. Research their buying behavior to understand if your product or service might interest them.

For instance, if you're selling something to a recently funded company whose decision-makers need a solution you offer, cold emailing them with a tailored pitch shows you've done your homework. This is a prime example of how researching and developing buyer personas can pay off.

3. Social media stalking (In a good way) 

Look at your prospect's LinkedIn profiles, Twitter feeds, and publicly available info.

For instance, you can check for recent accomplishments, shared interests, or challenges they've shared in their latest LinkedIn post or X (former Twitter) updates.  This info is invaluable for personalizing your email.

However, keep it professional. Avoid discussing personal matters like family when sending a cold email. You can also consider connecting with them on social media before sending the cold email; it can help create a sense of familiarity.

The anatomy of a personalized Cold Email

After your research, you have created a list, and you know the personalization points you will use for your prospect. Let's break down how you can really personalize a cold email.

1. Subject line

This is the first thing your recipient sees. A cold email subject line is one of the most critical components of your email because no matter how tailored and relevant your body of the email is, you are never going to succeed if your subject line is not catchy because chances are that it might get lost between a number of emails that your recipients receive each day. 

Use their first name or reference something specific to grab their attention in the subject line. For example, “Are you looking for {Solution}, [Prospect's Name]?” or [First name], we have something you are looking for.

2. Greeting

Always use the recipient's name. It's a simple but effective way to start the content of your email on a personal note. Using the first name while greeting makes your recipient feel good, and honestly, it makes it sound better than a regular greeting like “Hi there,” 

3. Introduction

Start with your name, tell them who you are and why you are mailing them so that the mail should be clear in the opening lines, and establish a connection. Mention something you have in common, such as a mutual contact or a recent event related to their industry. Or you can be more relevant if the prospect is relevant to you and discuss the problem they are facing; maybe they were browsing your website or looking at your social media profile.

Use this kind of data to make the email relevant during the introduction. This will pique their interest in reading the email further.

4. Value proposition

The next part is to state the value you're offering clearly. How can your product or service solve their problem or help them achieve their goals?

Be concise and to the point. Explain their challenges, where they might need your help, and how you can help them.

5. Customized content

Share relevant content or resources demonstrating your understanding of their needs to create an effective cold email. If you have a success story that aligns with their situation, share it. 

For example, you can share a case study of how you helped a client similar to them achieve success, or you can talk about big brands you have worked with to make them feel that you are a legitimate business and serious. You can examine the same in this cold email example. 

6. Call to Action (CTA)

End your every cold email with a clear CTA and show what you want the recipient to do next?

Whether it's scheduling a call, a free consultation you might want to offer, downloading a resource, or simply replying to the email, make it easy for them to take the next step. Don’t forget to add your calendar links or resource links.

7. Signature

Sign off with your name, your role in the company, and your company name.

A quick tip: Consider including your company’s professional logo with your email signature to add a personal touch and make the email seem more professional and legitimate. 

Note: Don’t forget to add an unsubscribe link at the end. You should always give them the option to opt out.

Best Tips and Practices to personalize your cold email campaigns

We have some basic ideas for personalizing your emails and creating the best cold email campaigns. Here are some tips to make your cold email and personalization even better.  

1. Personalizing by list size 

Cold email personalization takes a lot of effort, and it’s no joke that if you have a list with 1000 prospects, you might not be able to personalize every one.

You can always segment your personalization according to your list size and divide your list according to your most important prospects to the least essential prospects by calculating the revenue you will generate from them.

Basic personalization

If your list is too large you can do basic personalization. This includes the basic information about prospects like their first and last name, industry, and organization.

Although this isn’t much, it is better than your plain cold email. You can do this personalization for the prospects who yield less revenue.

Semi-personalization

The second group of prospects falls in the medium revenue range. You can elevate your personalization by including points like organizational or personal achievements and shared interests between you and your prospect. 

Hyper-personalization

The final group, with fewer prospects but higher revenue potential, deserves your utmost attention.

Craft cold emails after thorough research, addressing specific pain points that can help you generate maximum engagement and connect with them on a human level to maximize revenue. 

2. Stay Informed

This cold email best practice suggests you stay informed about your recipient by keeping up with their social media, X (formerly Twitter) handle, and company website. It is one of the best ways to achieve results.

This might help you create and hold a new conversation with them and gain their attention and engagement. ‍ ‍ ‍

You need to show them that you have researched them and their organization, and the best way to do it is by mentioning something unique about them or their organization. 

3. Use compliments

Using compliments in your personalized cold emails is like a secret weapon. You see when you genuinely praise someone, it creates a connection. It's basic psychology – people like to be appreciated.

So, when you compliment the recipient in your cold email copy, it makes them warm up to you. And immediately, like you, they are more interested in listening to you.

4. Use email automation tools

If you are doing a mass outreach, the right cold email automation tools can make personalizing emails easier.

You can create cold email templates for each kind of personalization and research the personalization points, resulting in less time wasted writing emails for each person. It will give you more time to research your prospects. 

You can add variables in the email and research your personalization points according to them. E.g {First name}, {Company}, {Services}. All of these variables will include the data you research about your prospect.

5. Analyzing results and A/B testing

Use different methods and personalization points and test your emails using small parts of your list with every method. Analyze results to see what’s working and what’s not.Even if you are not getting any email replies, checking open and click-through rates (CTRs) is one of the best methods to analyze your email engagement.

Once you’ve analyzed your results, you can choose one of your personalization methods and scale your outreach to its maximum potential.

Ready to enhance your cold email outreach with personalization?

As you know, sales outreach can be done through various ways, including cold calls, email, video, etc., but do you know any of such ways would go in vain if you make it look personalized?

Personalization is the secret sauce that can turn a skeptical prospect into a loyal customer. It's about making your recipients feel valued and understood. 

Talking about email this time, investing time in research, crafting tailored messages, and genuinely connecting with your prospects can urge your customers to open your email.

It can also dramatically increase your average cold email response rates and, ultimately, your conversion rates. You can apply this method in any type of cold email you want, including sales email, first email, follow-up email, etc.

Remember, personalization isn't a one-size-fits-all strategy. It requires effort, creativity, and a genuine desire to build meaningful relationships. 

So, the next time you hit “send” on a cold email, ask yourself: Have I done my homework? Have I shown the recipient that I genuinely care about their needs? If yes, you're on the right path to mastering the art of personalization in cold email outreach.

For further assistance or help from our advisers, feel free to contact us.

Frequently Asked Questions